Disturbing Behavior (1998)

In the seemingly idyllic town of Cradle Bay, newcomer Steve Clark swiftly discovers a disquieting undercurrent beneath the surface of high school life. The "Blue Ribbons," an exclusive clique, project an unnerving image of flawless academic achievement and pristine morality. However, their perfection, mirroring that of the town itself, feels unsettlingly manufactured. When Steve's rebellious confidant, Gavin, inexplicably integrates into their ranks, Steve, alongside fellow outcast Rachel, embarks on a quest to unearth the sinister reality behind Cradle Bay's facade. The truth awaits them, shrouded in secrets and unsettling conformity.